The One With All The Chocolate


It’s the week of love people! The week where calories don’t count if they are in the form of chocolate. I have always been a huge fan of Valentine’s Day. Whether I am in a relationship or not I love to celebrate with wine and a nice meal. My parents, however, like to celebrate by sending me candy and a barbershop quartet….to my office. All embarrassment aside my meal of choice for this lovely holiday is generally a steak. I am not sure why in my head February 14th=steak but i’m stuck with it.

Each year I do a different variation and this year I am getting a bit nostalgic. When I was 15 my family took a European vacation. While there were many fabulous aspects to this trip I can guarantee that the chocolate steak we had in Venice is sure to be a universal favorite. This steak had an incredible red wine and chocolate sauce accompanied by delicious fresh fruit. It sounds so strange but it was truly one of the most unusually delicious and memorable meals. I have searched for years and never found another recipe that comes close so i decided to piece together a few to create my own.

Before I debut this recipe let me reveal a secret. I have never cooked filet mignon. So this recipe is a double experiment. Turns out, cooking a filet is super easy AND makes you feel really cool. Basting the meat in dabs of butter infused with rosemary is quite the experience. I didn’t end up using the stove top to oven method because just over the stovetop mine was cooked enough. If I were putting a lighter sauce on top or eating the steak with something else I could probably give it some oven time for a little extra crisp.

Once I had the steaks cooked through and wrapped in foil to rest I realized I had a pretty solid sauce base so I turned down the heat and added a lot of garlic, a fair amount of red wine, a few dashes of chile powder, and a pinch of pepper and let it all reduce together. Because I was just adding to the cooking liquid I did not add anymore butter and I did not include beef stock as I had intended. Once the sauce is reduced to your liking, about a twenty minute process until dragging a spoon through it leaves a clear divide, turn off the heat and whisk in the dark chocolate pieces.

I used a 73% cacao dark chocolate bar from Trader Joe’s. Holy moly this takes this sauce up to 1 million. It looks and smells amazing. Something I didn’t do but wish I had at this point is strain it prior to topping the steaks. Don’t skip this step it adds to the luxury of a thick, creamy sauce with complex but not individual tastes. You don’t want to randomly chomp down on a piece of garlic or rosemary to ruin a bite.

Steak with a Chocolate, Red Wine Sauce

AMAZING for special occasions such as Valentine’s Day. Brings the wow factor with limited effort.

  • Prep Time: 5m
  • Cook Time: 27m
  • Total Time: 32m
  • Serves: 2
  • Yield: 2 steaks


  • filets
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 teaspoon butter
  • 2 sprigs rosemary
  • 2 tablespoons minced garlic
  • 1 1/2 cups red wine shiraz or shiraz/cab blend preferred
  • 1/4 cup dark chocolate (70% or more cacao) chopped
  • 2 teaspoons chile powder
  • 1 dash pepper


  1. Heat a heavy bottomed skillet to high heat and add olive oil. Rub filets liberally on both sides with salt and pepper
  2. Once olive oil is shimmering add filets to pan for 3-4 minutes. flip filets after 3-4 minutes and let them crisp on the other side for the same amount of time
  3. Once the other side has crisped add butter and rosemary to the pan and baste the filets for as long as you want depending on your done-ness preference. I basted for about 5 or six more minutes and they were about medium.
  4. Once meat is done to your liking wrap it in foil to rest. Turn down heat to medium-low and add garlic to pan
  5. Cook garlic until fragrant (2-3 minutes) and add red wine. Simmer for a few minutes and then add chile powder and pepper. Allow these to simmer together for about 20 minutes until you can pull a spoon through the liquid and see a clear separation on the bottom of the pan.
  6. At this point turn off the heat and whisk in chocolate. Once chocolate is fully melted and incorporated strain the sauce so you are just left with liquid gold.
  7. Top steaks with this delicious sauce and serve with whichever sides you prefer. I made cinnamon sweet potatoes and broccoli.
  8. Enjoy!

I paired this meal with some cinnamon topped sweet potatoes and steamed broccoli. The best part is you can use the leftover wine and chocolate for dessert :). Let me know if you try this chocolatey perfection or if you have another favorite steak sauce I need to try. Have a wonderful Valentine’s Day!



Share Post:

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.